Casey Key is a long and narrow stretch of land that serves as a barrier island between Nokomis and the Gulf of Mexico in Sarasota County. Casey Key is separated from continental Florida by Blackburn Bay, which is part of the Intracoastal Waterway. Due to the island’s unique geography and natural beauty, homes in Casey Key are considered some of the most exclusive and valuable real estate opportunities in the Sunshine State.
The small area of Casey Key is dotted with a few select neighborhoods that have some of the best views in the Sarasota Keys. Not all properties are waterfront homes, but they all have reasonable beach access. The northern section of Casey Key, which is part of Osprey, is home to the liveliest neighborhoods and most charming real estate in Southwest Florida.
Spectacular single-family homes are the norm in Casey Key. The architectural styles range from Old Florida cottages to modest Mediterranean-style homes. There are some very impressive custom-built estates on the island that emulate the Key West and Island Colonial styles. Luxury homes with private docks are perfect for boaters who want to sail right into the Intracoastal Waterway and quickly find their way to the azure waters of the Gulf of Mexico or navigate inland to Oscar Scherer State Park. All the neighborhoods in Casey Key are carefully maintained and are legendary for their immaculate landscaping.
Casey Key does not have too much commercial activity on the island. Residents here enjoy their privacy, but they are by no means isolated. The island is connected to Nokomis by Albee Road to the south and Blackburn Point Road to the north. Casey Key residents only need to drive a few minutes to leave the island and find shopping, dining, golf, tennis, cultural activities, nature preserves and all the amenities that Southwest Florida is famous for.
Casey Key Florida Homes for Sale
Lot Size9,147 sqft
Home Size2,307 sq ft
Days on Market3
Lot Size40,946 sqft
Home Size3,906 sq ft
Days on Market6
Lot Size22,651 sqft
Home Size3,571 sq ft
Days on Market8
Home Size2,303 sq ft
Days on Market8
Lot Size20,037 sqft
Home Size4,172 sq ft
Days on Market10
See all Luxury Homes for Sale in Casey Key Florida.
(all data current as of 1/17/2019)
Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Read full disclaimer.