Bay Isles Homes for Sale | Longboat Key Florida

Bay Isles is one of the most prestigious gated communities on Longboat Key, offering a rare blend of luxury homes, waterfront estates, maintenance-free residences, private beach access, and secure island living. Located near the heart of Longboat Key, Bay Isles is known for its beautifully landscaped grounds, guarded entrances, and exclusive lifestyle amenities.

This private community captures much of what makes Longboat Key real estate so desirable, with a wide variety of residential options ranging from elegant single-family homes and courtyard residences to townhomes, villas, and impressive waterfront estates with private docks.

Homes in Bay Isles Longboat Key

Bay Isles features approximately 200 residences spread throughout a collection of private neighborhoods behind two 24-hour guarded gates. Buyers will find a wide range of property styles, including spacious single-family homes, luxury waterfront estates, maintenance-free villas, townhomes, and courtyard homes.

Many properties feature private swimming pools, lush tropical landscaping, outdoor entertaining areas, lake views, golf course views, or waterfront settings with boating access. Larger estates may include private docks, expansive terraces, custom interiors, and sweeping views of Sarasota Bay or the surrounding waterways.

The variety of homes within Bay Isles makes it appealing to buyers seeking the privacy of a gated community along with access to the island’s beach, boating, golf, shopping, and dining amenities.

Community Amenities

Private gated community
Two 24-hour guarded entrances
Private Bay Isles Beach Club
Waterfront and golf course homes
Maintenance-free villas and townhomes
Walking trails and landscaped common areas
Fountains, lakes, and tropical landscaping
Optional access to nearby golf, marina, and club amenities

Location

Bay Isles is centrally located on Longboat Key, offering convenient access to the island’s shopping, dining, marinas, golf, and beach destinations. The community is close to Bay Isles shopping, the Longboat Key Club area, and everyday conveniences along the island.

Its central location also makes it convenient to travel south toward St. Armands Circle, Lido Key, and Downtown Sarasota or north toward Anna Maria Island and Bradenton.

Nearby Beaches and Attractions

One of the defining advantages of Bay Isles is access to the private Bay Isles Beach Club on the Gulf of Mexico. This exclusive beachfront amenity allows residents to enjoy Longboat Key’s white sand shoreline in a private and peaceful setting.

Residents are also close to boating, golf, waterfront dining, marinas, and island recreation. Nearby destinations include St. Armands Circle, Lido Key, Sarasota, and Bradenton.

Similar Communities

Coreys Landing – Gated Bay Isles neighborhood offering maintenance-free homes, waterfront settings, and access to private beach amenities.
Harbour Oaks – Private Bay Isles community with luxury homes, mature landscaping, and convenient access to beach and club amenities.
Grand Bay – Luxury bayfront condominium community behind the gates of Bay Isles with sweeping water views and resort-style amenities.
Country Club Shores – Waterfront Longboat Key neighborhood known for canal-front homes, boating access, and proximity to Longboat Key Club.
Longboat Key Club – Premier island community offering luxury residences, golf, tennis, marina access, and resort-style amenities.