Spice Bay is an exclusive gated community on the southern end of Siesta Key, located along Midnight Pass Road overlooking Roberts Bay. Set on an intimate eight-acre parcel, this private enclave features luxury homes, West Indies-inspired architecture, waterfront views, and a serene coastal setting.
With only 14 homes, Spice Bay appeals to buyers seeking gated privacy, refined design, boating opportunities, and convenient access to the beaches, dining, and recreation of Siesta Key.
Homes in Spice Bay Siesta Key
Spice Bay features luxury single-family homes with elegant coastal architecture, spacious interiors, private outdoor living areas, and tropical landscaping. Many homes offer views of Roberts Bay, private pools, lanais, balconies, and refined finishes designed for relaxed island living.
Homes in Spice Bay generally range from approximately 2,500 to 5,500 square feet, offering generous space for full-time living, seasonal ownership, or a private Siesta Key retreat.
The community’s West Indies-inspired design, limited number of homes, waterfront setting, and maintenance-free lifestyle make Spice Bay one of the more distinctive luxury neighborhoods on Siesta Key.
Community Amenities
- Exclusive gated Siesta Key community
- Only 14 luxury homes
- Eight-acre private setting
- Approximately 450 feet of waterfront
- Roberts Bay views from select homes
- West Indies-inspired architecture
- Private boat slips available for purchase
- Maintenance-free lifestyle
- Luxury single-family residences
- Tropical landscaping
- Close proximity to Turtle Beach, Crescent Beach, and South Siesta Key dining
Location
Spice Bay is located on the southern end of Midnight Pass Road on Siesta Key. This peaceful location offers privacy while keeping residents close to Turtle Beach, Crescent Beach, Point of Rocks, boating areas, waterfront dining, and mainland Sarasota conveniences.
Siesta Key Village, South Siesta Key restaurants, Stickney Point, marinas, shopping, cultural venues, and everyday services are all within convenient driving distance.
Nearby Beaches and Attractions
Residents of Spice Bay enjoy access to the quieter south end of Siesta Key, with Turtle Beach, Crescent Beach, Roberts Bay, and nearby boating waters offering opportunities for kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, shelling, and sunset views.
Nearby destinations include Turtle Beach, Crescent Beach, Point of Rocks, Roberts Bay, South Siesta Key dining, Siesta Key Village, boating areas, Jim Neville Marine Preserve, and Sarasota.
Similar Communities
- Sanderling Club – Gated Siesta Key luxury community with private beach access, marina, tennis courts, and estate homes.
- Hidden Harbor – Exclusive Siesta Key waterfront neighborhood with luxury homes, boating access, large lots, and Roberts Bay views.
- Point Crisp – Prestigious Siesta Key waterfront neighborhood with estate homes, bay views, and boating access.
- Cocoanut Bayou – Private Siesta Key neighborhood known for luxury homes, large lots, mature landscaping, and a tranquil waterfront setting.
- Royal Palm Harbor – Private Siesta Key waterfront enclave with deep-water docks, canal views, boating access, and Siesta Beach nearby.
Aerial Slideshow of Spice Bay Siesta Key
Spice Bay Homes for Sale | Siesta Key Florida
With its gated setting, limited number of luxury homes, waterfront views, West Indies-inspired architecture, boat slip opportunities, and peaceful south Siesta Key location, Spice Bay remains a desirable island community. View current Spice Bay homes for sale below if inventory is available.
Spice Bay Siesta Key FAQ
Where is Spice Bay located?
Spice Bay is located on the southern end of Midnight Pass Road on Siesta Key, Florida, overlooking Roberts Bay.
Is Spice Bay a gated community?
Yes, Spice Bay is an exclusive gated community on Siesta Key.
How many homes are in Spice Bay?
Spice Bay includes only 14 luxury single-family homes.
Does Spice Bay offer boating access?
Yes, private boat slips may be available for purchase within the community, depending on availability.
What is near Spice Bay Siesta Key?
Spice Bay is close to Turtle Beach, Crescent Beach, Point of Rocks, Roberts Bay, South Siesta Key dining, Siesta Key Village, boating areas, Jim Neville Marine Preserve, and Sarasota.
