Jewfish Key is a private island community located just off the northeastern tip of Longboat Key, offering one of the most unique residential settings in Southwest Florida. Accessible only by boat, this secluded barrier island appeals to buyers seeking privacy, waterfront living, natural beauty, and a true island lifestyle.
Unlike traditional Longboat Key neighborhoods connected by road, Jewfish Key offers a rare sense of escape while still remaining close to Longboat Key, Anna Maria Island, Sarasota Bay, and the Gulf of Mexico. The island is known for its waterfront homes, private docks, nature preserve areas, and exceptional boating access.
Homes on Jewfish Key Island
Jewfish Key was originally two separate islands before dredging operations connected them into a single island of approximately 38 acres. Today, part of the island is preserved as natural habitat, while the residential portion features a limited collection of waterfront homes and homesites.
Properties on Jewfish Key range from beach cottages and island retreats to larger Mediterranean-inspired and coastal estate homes. Many residences offer private dockage, open water views, outdoor living areas, and direct access to boating, fishing, kayaking, and paddleboarding.
The island’s low-density setting, mandatory preservation association membership, and boat-only access help maintain the privacy and natural character that make Jewfish Key so distinctive.
Community Amenities
- Private island setting
- Boat-only access
- Waterfront homes and homesites
- Private docks on select properties
- Community docks and piers
- Nature preserve areas
- Buried utility lines
- Exceptional boating and fishing access
- Close proximity to Longboat Key and Anna Maria Island
Location
Jewfish Key is located just off the northeastern tip of Longboat Key near the waters between Longboat Key and Anna Maria Island. Because the island is not connected by road, residents access their homes by boat from nearby docks and marinas.
The Longboat Key municipal docks are only a short boat ride away, providing convenient access to island shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences. Anna Maria Island and Coquina Beach are also nearby by water.
Nearby Beaches and Attractions
Residents of Jewfish Key enjoy a lifestyle centered around boating, fishing, wildlife viewing, and quiet island living. The surrounding waters offer access to Sarasota Bay, Longboat Pass, the Gulf of Mexico, and nearby barrier island destinations.
Nearby attractions include Longboat Key, Anna Maria Island, Bradenton Beach, Coquina Beach, Bay Isles, marinas, waterfront restaurants, and the Gulf beaches of Longboat Key.
Similar Communities
- Dream Island – Exclusive Longboat Key waterfront neighborhood with bay views, boating access, and private island-style living.
- Sleepy Lagoon – Established Longboat Key neighborhood with waterfront homes, canal access, and a quiet coastal atmosphere.
- Emerald Harbor – Waterfront Longboat Key boating community featuring canal-front homes, private docks, and Old Florida charm.
- Longbeach – Historic north Longboat Key neighborhood offering Old Florida character, cottages, and walkable island living.
- Conrad Beach – Beachside Longboat Key community known for Key West-style homes, beach access, and a relaxed coastal atmosphere.
Aerial Slideshow Jewfish Key Island Florida
Jewfish Key Homes for Sale | Longboat Key Florida
With its private island setting, boat-only access, waterfront homes, and preserve surroundings, Jewfish Key remains one of the most unique residential communities near Longboat Key. View current Jewfish Key homes for sale below if inventory is available.
Jewfish Key Longboat Key FAQ
Where is Jewfish Key located?
Jewfish Key is located just off the northeastern tip of Longboat Key, Florida, near Anna Maria Island and Longboat Pass.
Can you drive to Jewfish Key?
No, Jewfish Key is a private island that can only be accessed by boat.
What types of homes are on Jewfish Key?
Jewfish Key features waterfront cottages, coastal homes, Mediterranean-inspired residences, and luxury island estates.
Do homes on Jewfish Key have boat docks?
Some properties on Jewfish Key offer private docking space, and residents may also use community island docks and piers.
What is near Jewfish Key?
Jewfish Key is close by boat to Longboat Key, Anna Maria Island, Coquina Beach, Longboat Pass, Sarasota Bay, marinas, restaurants, and Gulf Coast beaches.
