Stillwater is a gated residential community in Englewood, Florida, offering single-family homes in a convenient Sarasota County location. The neighborhood features established homes, landscaped streets, lakes, and a quiet residential setting near shopping, medical services, Old Englewood, and the beaches of Manasota Key.
Stillwater appeals to buyers looking for a deed-restricted community with larger homesites, lake and preserve views, and convenient access to both everyday amenities and Gulf Coast recreation. Homes within the community vary in size, floor plan, age, renovations, outdoor living areas, and water or preserve views.
Stillwater Homes
Stillwater consists primarily of detached single-family homes located along streets such as Clear Lake Drive, Lake Victoria Court, Lake Tahoe Court, Montigello Court, and portions of Abercrombie Avenue. Many residences were built during the 2000s and feature one-story Florida floor plans with attached garages, screened lanais, and outdoor living areas.
Depending on the property, buyers may find homes overlooking neighborhood lakes, landscaped common areas, or preserve-style surroundings. Individual homes can vary significantly in square footage, interior updates, pool features, lot size, and view, so buyers should compare the specific features of each available property.
Stillwater Community Features
Stillwater offers a gated residential environment with community features that may include:
- Gated neighborhood entrance
- Single-family homes
- Neighborhood lakes
- Landscaped common areas
- Deed-restricted ownership
- Community recreational facilities in applicable association sections
- Convenient access to shopping and medical services
- Easy access to Manasota Key beaches
Stillwater includes multiple association sections, so HOA fees, included services, recreational amenities, pet policies, rental restrictions, and maintenance responsibilities may vary. Buyers should review the current association documents for the specific property they are considering.
Location in Englewood
Stillwater is located in Englewood’s 34223 ZIP code in Sarasota County. The community provides convenient access to South McCall Road, Pine Street, medical facilities, grocery stores, restaurants, and other everyday services throughout Englewood.
Historic Old Englewood and Dearborn Street are also nearby, offering locally owned restaurants, shops, community events, and a walkable small-town setting.
Near Manasota Key Beaches
Residents of Stillwater are conveniently located near Manasota Key and the Gulf of Mexico. Englewood Beach, Manasota Beach, and other coastal recreation areas provide opportunities for swimming, boating, fishing, kayaking, paddle sports, and enjoying Gulf Coast sunsets.
The neighborhood is also close to Lemon Bay and the waterways surrounding Englewood, giving residents additional opportunities for boating and outdoor recreation.
Stillwater vs. Villas at Stillwater
Buyers should note that Stillwater and Villas at Stillwater are related but distinct residential searches. Stillwater primarily includes detached single-family homes, while Villas at Stillwater consists of attached villa-style residences within the broader Stillwater area.
Stillwater should also not be confused with Shores at Stillwater, a separate newer residential development located elsewhere in Englewood.
Similar Englewood Communities
- Villas at Stillwater – Attached villa residences offering a lower-maintenance option within the Stillwater area.
- Boca Royale – A gated Englewood community offering single-family homes, villas, golf, and recreational amenities.
- Oyster Creek – A gated golf community with homes near Englewood’s beaches and shopping.
- Park Forest – A gated residential community offering single-family homes and community amenities.
- Hammocks Preserve – A gated Englewood neighborhood with newer single-family homes and a residential setting near area amenities.
Stillwater Homes for Sale | Englewood Florida
View current Stillwater homes for sale below. Availability can vary in this established Englewood community. Buyers can also explore additional Englewood homes, condos, villas, and neighborhoods.
Frequently Asked Questions About Stillwater
Where is Stillwater located?
Stillwater is located in Englewood, Florida 34223 in Sarasota County, near South McCall Road, Pine Street, Old Englewood, and Manasota Key.
What type of homes are in Stillwater?
Stillwater primarily consists of detached single-family homes, including residences with lake, landscaped, and preserve-style views.
Is Stillwater a gated community?
Yes. Stillwater is a gated, deed-restricted residential community. Association requirements and included services can vary by section.
Is Stillwater the same as Villas at Stillwater?
No. Stillwater primarily includes detached single-family homes, while Villas at Stillwater consists of attached villa-style residences and should be searched separately.
Is Stillwater the same as Shores at Stillwater?
No. Shores at Stillwater is a separate newer residential community in Englewood and should not be confused with the established Stillwater neighborhood.
Interested in Stillwater or other Englewood communities? Contact Wendy Lynn | eXp Realty for help comparing available homes, HOA information, nearby neighborhoods, and other Englewood real estate options.
